CBRS demos, 5G talk highlight venue news at Mobile World Congress

A legendary telecom building in downtown Los Angeles, the city that was the home of last week’s Mobile World Congress Americas show. Credit all photos: Paul Kapustka, MSR (click on any picture for a larger image)

Some live demonstrations of wireless devices using spectrum in the Citizens Broadband Radio Service (CBRS) topped the venue-specific news at last week’s Mobile World Congress Americas trade show in Los Angeles.

At Angel Stadium in nearby Anaheim, a group of companies led by Connectivity Wireless and JMA teamed up to do some live demonstrations of use cases for the CBRS spectrum, a swath of 150 MHz in the 3.5 GHz range that uses the cellular LTE standard for device communications. One demo we heard about reportedly used a Motorola push-to-talk (PTT) handset to carry on a conversation from a suite behind home plate to centerfield, a “home run” distance of at least 400 feet.

Mobile Sports Report, which doesn’t often attend trade shows, found lots for venue technology professionals to be interested in at the show, including the live demonstrations of CBRS-connected devices in the JMA booth that included handsets, headsets and standalone digital displays using CBRS for back-end connectivity. MSR also sat down with Heidi Hemmer, Verizon’s vice president of technology, to talk about 5G for stadiums and why the push for the new cellular standard doesn’t mean the end of Wi-Fi. Read on for highlights of our visit to LA, which also included an interview with Boingo’s new CEO Mike Finley and with Paul Challoner, a CBRS expert at Ericsson.

Look at me, I can hear… centerfield

MSR wasn’t able to make it to the press event held at Angel Stadium, but we heard from multiple sources that the trial CBRS network installed there for a short stint in October by Connectivity Wireless and JMA performed as advertised, especially with the aforementioned full-field PTT talk between two devices, with one of those more than 400 feet away from the CBRS radio.

The worth of the ability for a device to communicate to a access-point radio at such a distance should be clearly apparent to venue wireless professionals, who may want to tap into CBRS networks to increase connectivity inside their venues. With more powerful radios than Wi-Fi and connectivity that utilizes the mobility and security of the LTE standard, teams and venues may look to CBRS for back-of-house communications that would benefit from being separated from the shared Wi-Fi infrastructures. While we are still waiting for the first publicly announced contract win for CBRS in venues — even the Angels are still weighing the decision to go forward with a CBRS deal — being able to show networks working live is a big step forward in the “is it real” phase.

Connecting digital displays, and more PTT

If there was a true “hot spot” for CBRS activity on the MWC show floor, it was at the JMA booth, where the wireless infrastructure company was running a live CBRS network with all kinds of devices running off it. JMA, which was showing its own CBRS radio cell (a kind of access point-on-steroids radio that will provide connectivity to client devices in a CBRS network) as well as a version of its XRAN virtual network core software, had a working prototype of one of the first commercially announced CBRS networks, a wireless deployment of digital displays for the parking lots at the American Dream shopping mall in New Jersey.

A prototype of the CBRS-connected displays JMA is installing at the American Dream mall. (Don’t miss the Jimmy Hoffa joke at the bottom)

According to JMA director of markets and solutions Kurt Jacobs, the 600-acre parking lot at the huge new mall near the Meadowlands (it will have an amusement park and an indoor skiing slope, among other attractions and stores) was a perfect place to harness the ability of CBRS networks. The displays, large LED signs that can change dynamically to assist with parking instructions and directions, needed wireless connectivity to provide the back-end information.

But after considering a traditional deployment with fiber backhaul and Wi-Fi — which Jacobs said would have cost the mall at least $3 million to deploy with construction taking 6 months or more — the mall turned to JMA and a CBRS network deployment, which Jacobs said will use nine radios and 13 antennas to cover the signs, which will be spread out at key traffic junctions. Total cost? About a half-million dollars. Total deployment time? About eight weeks, according to Jacobs. Jacobs said the system will also eventually be able to support mobile CBRS radios inside security vehicles for real time updates from the lots.

Verizon to cover all NFL stadiums with 5G… and lots of Wi-Fi

Heidi Hemmer, Verizon

Heidi Hemmer, Verizon

MSR was fortunate enough to get on the appointment schedule of Heidi Hemmer, Verizon’s vice president of technology. A few days after Verizon had publicly announced a spate of 5G deployments in NBA arenas, Hemmer doubled down on the carrier’s 5G commitment to NFL stadiums, saying the current list of 13 stadiums with some kind of Verizon 5G coverage would soon expand to the entire league.

While hype is heavy around 5G — if you’re a football fan you’ve no doubt seen the Verizon TV commercial where Verizon’s technology development director Eric Nagy walks around various stadiums touting the service — Hemmer was clear that 5G is just part of a full-spectrum stadium wireless solution, one that will likely include 4G LTE as well as Wi-Fi well into the future.

While Verizon is clearly proud of its cutting-edge 5G deployments, the company is also probably the biggest provider of Wi-Fi networks in large stadiums, with many NFL and even some large colleges having Verizon-specific SSIDs for Verizon customers, usually as part of a sponsorship deal from Verizon. Verizon is also a big bankroller of distributed antenna system (DAS) deployments inside stadiums, sometimes acting as the neutral host and other times participating as a tenant on the in-venue cellular networks.

A fuzzy shot of a 5G antenna in the wild at Empower Field at Mile High in Denver

According to Hemmer, having as much connectivity as possible allows Verizon to provide the best possible experience for its customers. The eventual end goal, she said, would be a world where fans’ phones “dynamically” connect to whatever network is best suited for their needs, from Wi-Fi to 4G to 5G. Currently, many of the Verizon Wi-Fi deployments will automatically connect Verizon customers to Wi-Fi in a venue where they have previously logged on to the network.

And while the millimeter-wave 5G deployments inside stadiums right now don’t come close to covering the full space of any venue (at the Denver Broncos’ Empower Field at Mile High, for instance, there are only 16 5G antennas in the building), they do provide a different level of connectivity, with much faster download speeds and less latency. Hemmer said those characteristics could spawn an entirely new class of services for fans like better instant-replay video or advanced statistics. While MSR hasn’t personally tested any 5G networks, the early word is that in some situations download speeds can be in the gigabit-per-second range.

“Speeds are important to our customers and 5G can really push up the fan experience,” Hemmer said.

New Boingo CEO bullish on venues business

Mobile World Congress was also MSR’s first chance to meet Mike Finley, who became Boingo’s CEO back in February. A former Qualcomm executive, Finley said that Boingo’s history of being a neutral-host provider for venues should continue to drive more business in that realm, especially as newer complex possibilities like CBRS and Wi-Fi 6 networks emerge.

“We are satisfying a need” that venues have for connectivity expertise, Finley said, especially when it comes to relationships with wireless carriers.

At MWC, Boingo was part of the CBRS Alliance’s multi-partner booth space promoting the OnGo brand for CBRS gear and services. In its space Boingo was showing its new converged virtualized core offering (which was using JMA’s XRAN product) with a live combined CBRS and Wi-Fi 6 network running side by side. A booth representative with an iPhone 11 device was able to quickly switch between the two networks, offering a glimpse at the potential future networking choices venues may be able to offer.

Ericsson Dots target stadiums, CBRS

In its large MWC booth, connectivity gear provider Ericsson had a special display for venue equipment, including a weather-hardened version of its Radio Dot System that Ericsson booth reps said should be appearing soon in some U.S. sporting venues. Ericsson was also showing some Dots that it said would support CBRS, a service Ericsson sees great promise for in venues.

Paul Challoner, Ericsson’s vice president for network product solutions, said it will be interesting to see whether or not venues will need to pursue licenses for CBRS spectrum when those are auctioned off next year, or whether venues will choose to use the unlicensed parts of the CBRS spectrum. Like others at the show, Challoner was excited about Apple’s decision to include support for CBRS bands in the iPhone 11 line — “it’s a fantastic boost for the CBRS ecosystem,” he said.

More MWC photos below!

Some of the Ericsson Dot radios designed for inside venue use

A prototype digital display kiosk from JMA, Intel and LG MRI, with space up top for CBRS gear

Another wireless-enabled display kiosk, this one in the Ericsson booth. Looks like wireless and digital displays are the next hot product.

Westfield brings high-density Wi-Fi to LA’s Century City mall

We’re gonna shop in Century City… Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR (click on any photo for a larger image)

It might not look like a stadium, but if you take a close examination of the technology being put into the renovation of the Westfield Century City mall, you’ll see a familiar use of wireless and networking technology aimed at improving the visitor experience while also benefiting the mall’s bottom line.

Some of that has to do with the fact that the mall’s new IT team includes veterans of the sports-arena networking market; the other has to do with the fact that shopping malls, like stadiums, struggle with some of the same issues around bringing connectivity to crowded public areas and trying to connect digitally with the people there, in this case shoppers and visitors rather than ticket holders.

So as part of a $1 billion redevelopment of the historic mall space, bringing high density wireless connectivity to the venue via a Wi-Fi network was a necessity for mall owner Westfield, as it seeks to enable the digitally connected future of the next-generation of bricks and mortar shopping malls. Now nearing the completion of its makeover, which is being rolled out in the fall of 2017, the “new” Westfield Century City will eventually be host to more than 1.3 million square feet of commercial space, with more than 200 shops and restaurants, and other amenities including a mid-mall concert and entertainment space with professional staging and lighting infrastructure.

A Wi-Fi AP nestles in with other components in a mall walkway. Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR

The historic shopping spot on Santa Monica Boulevard is also now getting a dose of newly designed outdoor gathering spaces, from hanging couch-beds to small grassy hills where visitors can just hang out and connect as part of their Century City experience. Having reliable, high-performing Wi-Fi to cover those spaces was a necessary shopping-list item, according to Denise Taylor, chief information officer for Westfield and point person for the new network and all its connected features at not just Westfield Century City but for other similar ongoing projects at some of the company’s 35 mall properties in the U.S. and the U.K.

Technology enables the new mall experience

Editor’s note: This profile is an excerpt from our latest STADIUM TECH REPORT, our Summer 2017 issue that has in-depth profiles of network deployments at the Atlanta Braves’ new SunTrust Park, the Colorado Rockies’ Coors Field, and a profile of a new Wi-Fi network at Red Bull Arena. DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE COPY of the report today!

In an age when shopping malls may seem less relevant due to online shopping, many of the larger malls worldwide are rapidly shifting their business models to become more of a destination location for entertainment events, eating or “showroom” shopping, instead of just a place to go and buy things. And in a world where staying connected is as accepted and expected as breathing, a mall without wireless connectivity sounds like a place nobody would want to visit.

“I knew I had to integrate a physical and digital environment,” said Taylor, who left stadium-ownership concern AEG (where she oversaw tasks like bringing wireless networks to stadiums like LA’s Staples Center) to head up Westfield’s digital departments a couple years ago. “A big part of the mall transition was [installing] enabling technology.”

One of the new ‘hanging couch’ gathering areas. Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR

Since its opening in 1964, Century City has been known for being part of the wave of “outdoor” shopping malls, becoming part of the cultural landscape of LA and the Southern California lifestyle. (It was even the subject of a song by rockers Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers.) But like many sports venues that have been around awhile, these days Century City was lacking in a modern digital infrastructure to connect with its digital-device carrying customers.

According to Taylor, before the makeover project started the mall had no communication equipment rooms, no network backbone and maybe a couple hundred digital “endpoints,” including security cameras and intercoms. When the renovation is complete, Westfield Century City will have more than 2,000 end devices, including approximately 515 Wi-Fi APs, numerous digital displays, directories and LED sign boards.

One of the centerpieces of the renovation is a dedicated event space called The Terrace, which will be booked in part by Westfield’s own event production team.

The event space is just part of the new business plan for the mall and its visitors, a model for the future that includes on-location digital advertising not just for mall-based retailers but also for other brands who want to connect with the people at the mall, either through digital displays or app-based communications. While some of the plans are still concepts, without a baseline of a high-performing wireless network, none of the future ideas would be possible.

Ward Ross (L) and Denise Taylor

“If there is a fashion show at the mall event space, it’s important for visitors to be able to share what’s happening right at that moment,” said Taylor. “That called for a big shift as to what a good Wi-Fi experience was.”

Building for stadium-type foot traffic every day

If there was one thing that “floored” Taylor coming into the job, it was the steady, unending flow of people into the venue — a pace and total much different from stadiums, where people arrive sporadically for games and concerts.

“What really surprised me was the footfall,” said Taylor during an on-site visit by Mobile Sports Report in May, after the mall’s Phase 1 opening in April.

With its cellular system still tied up in the terms of a previous contract, Westfield Century City turned to Wi-Fi to bring a higher level of wireless connectivity to its public spaces, teaming up with Cisco and CDW for Wi-Fi gear and implementation efforts. Taylor also brought in veteran stadium technology expert Ward Ross as a consultant to help lead a somewhat different deployment at a venue that was never really closed for business, even as major construction efforts took place.

The need to ensure the deployment fit into the mall’s visible aesthetics, Taylor said, was particularly challenging, in an environment that “was never [originally] designed for central cabling or a communication infrastructure.” There was also the need to run construction efforts through leased retail spaces, a process that took “lots of effort and lots of conversations,” according to Taylor.

“The finished product is an amazing job of architecture,” said Taylor, who showed off the results of the work in a walk-around tour of the completed areas. “We had a big learning lesson on how to hide APs in a modern outdoor center.”

Though the initial public-facing service was gated to limit speeds, the plan is to eventually increase the bandwidth available to visitors as more of the mall’s construction and renovation is finished. With access to the “hidden” SSID that was running without restrictions, our tests over multiple places in the Phase 1 area saw Wi-Fi speeds in the 50 to 60 Mbps range for both download and upload.

Touchscreen kiosks, LED boards and better parking services

While video boards, Wi-Fi and a stadium app may be the primary technologies for stadiums these days, for shopping malls Taylor said there is a much different first priority: Where to park your car.

“I thought parking was important at arenas, but at malls the number one issue is parking locations,” Taylor said. At the time of our visit not all of Century City’s parking initiatives were live, but future shoppers there are in for pleasant surprises when it comes to the mall’s use of technology to eliminate as many parking pain points as possible. Ross and Taylor showed the under-development VIP reserved parking area, where customers can reserve and pay for a larger, centrally located spot that is held for them in a special garage area. When it’s working, customers will be able to pull into the spot by finding their name on an overhead screen — and then just leave when they are ready, without having to worry about parking tickets or paying attendants.

A ‘grassy knoll’ relaxing area. Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR

In other areas of the mall’s planned 5,000 parking spots, development is underway to bring a system of red and green lights that hover above each spot, letting drivers know if a space is open or not from far down the row.

“Both here and at Westfield Valley Fair [a mall in Silicon Valley] we’ve taken down lots and rebuilt and reconfigured them,” Taylor said. Future visitors can expect more wayfinding and tailored validation schemes for parking as Taylor seeks to use technology to bring “a VIP concept” to perhaps the most painful part of a visitor’s experience.

Once inside, more technology is visible in the form of touchscreen kiosks for mall directions, and big stadium-like LED screens for information and advertising. As the mall refurbishing is completed and the Wi-Fi network services more customers, Taylor is also looking ahead to when she can use network analytics to offer a more customized list of services to visitors via a forthcoming Century City app.

“We want to build a view of our customers, to let them know what’s relevant to them — if they want to see a show, or hear about a sale at Bloomingdale’s,” Taylor said.

The Wi-Fi network and its connected technologies also will let Westfield and Century City offer more information and opportunities to the retailers leasing space there, as well as other brands and companies who might want to advertise in one form or another to reach the demographic that physically shows up at the mall.

“Our primary customer used to be the retailers,” said Taylor of the role of mall-based IT. “Now we reach consumers, retailers here as well as other brands who are looking to connect. It’s a huge shift in thinking.”

Artist rendering of the event space being built at Century City.

Another artist rendering of what the completed renovation will look like.

Red and green lights will alert drivers to taken or open parking spots. Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR

A digital-display kiosk next to a concierge stand at the mall. Credit: Paul Kapustka, MSR

https://duwit.ukdw.ac.id/document/pengadaan/slot777/

https://mtsnupakis.sch.id/wp-content/zeusslot/

https://insankamilsidoarjo.sch.id/wp-content/slot-zeus/

https://smpbhayangkari1sby.sch.id/wp-content/slot-zeus/

https://alhikamsurabaya.sch.id/wp-content/slot-thailand/

https://mtsnupakis.sch.id/wp-content/bonus-new-member/

https://smptagsby.sch.id/wp-content/slot-bet-200/

https://lookahindonesia.com/wp-content/bonus-new-member/

https://ponpesalkhairattanjungselor.sch.id/wp-content/mahjong-slot/

https://mtsnupakis.sch.id/wp-content/slot777/

https://sdlabum.sch.id/wp-content/slot777/

https://sdlabumblitar.sch.id/wp-content/bonus-new-member/

https://sdlabumblitar.sch.id/wp-content/spaceman/

https://paudlabumblitar.sch.id/wp-content/spaceman/