Modevity Confirms Rise of the iPad Playbook in the NFL

Could Darrelle Revis be even better if the New York Jets used Modevity ARALOC Sports Platform?

A team’s NFL playbook is its lifeblood. And at least two teams are using iPads for competitive advantage. They’ve tapped a rising, 20-person company in Pennsylvania named Modevity LLC to handle encryption of data and rights management to distribute playbooks and scouting video to players, and to instantly turn off access to the playbook if a player is cut or traded.

Modevity in huddle with NFL’s early adopters

Modevity LLC specializes in digital rights management, and it has been winning business in its seven-year history by distributing such data as sensitive documents to board members at publicly traded companies and genome information to biologists at life sciences companies.  Its platform, called ARALOC, eschews a Web portal, and all its risks. All data, whether it is a text document, audio or video is encrypted at the server, and passed to the client application. Sophisticated rights management controls on the server side ensure only the right applications have access. That reduces the likelihood data will be pirated during distribution, prevents the data from being stored locally on a mobile device, and allows access to be turned off the instant it is necessary.

Seeing that a professional sport team’s playbook was every bit as sensitive as corporate board materials or advanced medical research, Modevity recently branched expanded into sports. To date, its foray is wildly successful. The NHL’s Phoenix Coyotes this week officially confirmed that it is using Modevity’s ARALOC Sports Platform. And, now, Modevity co-founder Tom Canova confirmed exclusively to MobileSportsReport.com that at least two NFL teams are using ARALOC to better prepare for football games. 

“I don’t think any team would argue with us that securing the playbook is first and foremost a concern of everyone in the league,” Canova said. “We are very confident we have the most secure mobile content platform out there.”

The Baltimore Ravens, Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Atlanta Falcons are reportedly using iPads to distribute team data in 2011, but if your favorite NFL team isn’t on that list don’t be discouraged. Canova would not name any NFL team as a client during an interview with MobileSportsReport.com, citing confidentiality agreements. And some teams distribute data via iPads without Modevity, which is risky business. In those scenarios, team officials load information manually on an iPad, which means that it could easily fall into the hands of Bill Belichick or another rival, if it were lost or stolen.  

Canova believes that the digital playbook will quickly spread across professional sports, and that ARALOC Sports Platform will be at the center of the mix.

“I don’t care if it is the NBA, NHL or NFL,” Canova said. “Everyone is trying to figure out in an automated process how (to get) their content distributed to a mobile device like an iPad.”

Playbook paradigm shift  

What’s happening with Modevity’s ARALOC Sports Platform is a paradigm shift in the way teams prepare for competition. Previously, teams relied on playbooks, and there were fines between $5,000 to $10,000 if you lost it. Using Modevity ARALOC Sports Platform, players can access digital versions of a team’s playbook on mobile devices, including Android devices. The players can annotate the plays with commentary, and share those comments with coaches, other players, or any other approved playbook on the system.

Some NFL teams are doing similar things with iPads but they don’t use ARALOC Sports Platform. Others are still distributing data via DVDs. Unless content is being distributed in an encrypted system with digital rights management, the information could be pirated, stolen or misappropriated, Canova pointed up.

“We are saying to the teams that you are at risk from the standpoint of content security,” Canova said. “You as a team have to be concerned that your playbook ewill get in the hands of some of your rivals.”

Interactive Scouting Reports

No professional sport relies on game film more heavily than the NFL, and ARALOC Sports Platform includes an application designed to maximize a team’s potential in the arena of scouting. All NFL teams have video production studios in their team facilities, and once film is cut it can be distributed using ARALOC Sports Platform to player devices. In fact, ARALOC includes a “telestration” feature, which allows coaches and players to mark up the film, and redistribute it to other approved team members.

So, if New York Jets cornerback Darrelle Revis — already one of the NFL’s most video-prepared players on any given Sunday — wanted a practice squad player to mimic a specific move San Diego Chargers’ wide receiver Vincent Jackson makes at the line of scrimmage, Revis could mark the film and send it to the practice squad player responsible for emulating Jackson. That’s a whole lot easier than sending an email, trying to explain it over the phone, or describing it on the practice field.

WHO REALLY USES ARALOCK?

Canova would not comment on teams using Modevity, but Fox Radio host Ben Maller previous made a brief mention that the Baltimore Ravens and Atlanta Falcons. Here is what was posted on BenMaller.com:

“The Baltimore Ravens have gotten rid of the old school paper playbook. They’re saving trees by giving players the playbook via on iPad. The National Football Post reports if the iPad is lost or stolen, or the player gets cut or traded, the Ravens have the ability to remotely erase all the information in the playbook. The Falcons have also shifted more to the use of Apple’s iPad.”

Blogger Simon Brown, who publishes Sports HR, reported that the Tampa Bay Buccaneers were using iPads to deliver plays. He was critical of the practice. Here is what he said:

“Sure, it seems like a cool idea for Tampa Bay to have its players download their playbooks to iPads. The problem is, aside from the usual dangers of players losing books or having them stolen, now the team is using a device that can be hacked. It’s great that the team wants to be hip (and green!), but it’s not worth the added danger.”  

Brown’s perspective is reasonable, but he didn’t pick up on the fact that security and digital rights management are involved if your NFL team uses ARALOC, or a similar platform. iPads are hands down the No. 1 tablet device in use by NFL players, and the advantage of being able to distribute up-to-the-minute playbook information and game video to the players at home or on the road — versus having them hang at our a team video facility — far outweigh the risks.

iPads on the sidelines

There are limits to the usefulness of the digital playbook. The NFL bans smartphones and iPads on the sidelines, according to a report on The Atlantic Wire. So, it won’t be until the 2012 NFL season, and would require a rules change, for you to see Modevity ARALOC Sports Platform used in a game situation.

GMs look to expand ARALOC use

It is expected that the 2012 NFL draft class will be evaluated by scouts passing information and annotated information using Modevity ARALOC Sports Platform, Canova said. And team officials are clamoring for Modevity to build applications that make contract negotiations as fail safe as the distribution of game film, Canova said.

“A number of front office executives have told me that they want to use the system in the secure distribution of other forms of confidential content, including content used in contract negotiations,” Canova said. “We’re seeing a lot of future thinking (from our NFL clients), and, as a technology provider, we are always interesting in how a customer might want to use ARALOC.”

Whether Mel Kiper Jr. starts using ARALOC to pass around data with his sources remains to be seen, but its clear that distribution of secure data to mobile devices via sophisticated digital rights management is the wave of the future in the NFL.

Courtesy of Modevity, here’s a diagram of its ARALOC solution:

 

 

 

 

 

 

Mobile Football: NBC a No-Show for Live Play-by-Play


In our ongoing search for the best mobile app for following live football play-by-play, on Sunday night the MSR research team decided to check out the options available from NBC, since the Peacock network carries the Sunday night game live on TV.

The verdict? For an Android smartphone user, NBC’s mobile play-by-play options are about as exciting as a handoff up the middle, far behind the functionality of services from ESPN and the NFL. There isn’t even a standalone app for Android phones — maybe the non-smartphone featured in NBC’s “mobile web” landing page is a tipoff — instead you are sent to a mobile-optimized web page that does give you a live score and can show details of the last play run, but that is all. We didn’t even get our turkey-and-chicken sausages halfway grilled before we switched from NBC’s mobile page back to ESPN, whose Gamecast app seemed to have new life on Sunday, without any of the non-updating problems we’d seen during previous weekends.

Since we are waiting for Tuesday’s expected new iPhone announcement to decide what our phone-upgrade strategy will be for the MSR Verizon account, it may be another week or two before we can check out Verizon’s NFL Mobile app. (Apparently NBC does have a standalone iPhone app, if you have knowledge of how this works please leave a comment below.) Until then we are putting ESPN and NFL 2011 in a tie for first, with Sprint TV a game behind and NBC’s offering at 0-4, looking for a new quarterback and maybe a new head coach.

The Ongoing Search: What’s the Best Mobile Play-by-Play Service for Football?

NFL 2011 mobile app, showing play by play. Good clear screen, detailed info.


There’s a whole lot of folks telling you that you can keep up on football games by using your mobile phone — but how well do the services actually work? In an ongoing search that will probably last all season long, your MSR crew (meaning me) will perform random acts of mobility, following NFL and college games via mobile to see if these services deliver, or if they fall incomplete.

Monday night my dinner-making grill-master duties coincided with the Monday night tilt between the Dallas Cowboys and the Washington Redskins, giving me a perfect chance to test out some of the mobile play-by-play services, like ESPN’s Gamecast, the NFL.com NFL 2011 app, and Sprint (my cell phone provider’s) Sprint Football app. The early verdict says: go with NFL 2011 as your starter, ESPN as your backup, and leave Sprint Football on the bench.

Though the NFL 2011 app has a little annoying banner ad at the bottom of the screen (the ESPN and Sprint services also have banner ads), its play-by-play updates are generally more informative than ESPN’s, giving it the edge in a basically even competition. Both services suffered from an annoying lag time between play posts — which, if your screen is set to go dark to save power like mine is, means you may occasionally have to hard refresh the device to keep the app alive. I’d buy a beer for the first service to add a simple “status” banner that could tell you something like “play under review” or “game in TV timeout” so that you aren’t stupidly staring at the screen waiting for an update.

The Sprint Football app. Basically unreadable, so bench this one in favor of other services.

I ruled out the Sprint app after less than a minute — though it might be informative it suffers from a too-cute design that uses a screen shot of a football field as a backdrop, making its white type illegible when you are looking at a post that blurs into the lines of the field on the drawing. Seriously, Sprint folks — does anyone there look at these things? You can’t read it. Change it, please.

Both the ESPN and the NFL app, which have sensible, clear backgrounds, both suffered mightily to keep up with a fast, complex play — like the interception thrown by Dallas QB Tony Romo in the first quarter that ended with a fumble out-of-bounds call that needed replay review. The play by play apps were no help, basically stalling and never getting around to explaining what happened — they just both picked up with Washington running plays in Dallas territory.

ESPN's Gamecast app, not live but even this wrapup shows the clear black-on-white format that works well.

Having access to a TV set just a few steps away from the barbecue gave me the ability to see how well the online apps were keeping up — and the answer was, not well at all. Both the ESPN and the NFL apps were at least three plays behind the live action; if you watch the Internet version of Gamecast on your PC you can even see that the Twitter stream embedded in the app usually has info that is ahead of the Gamecast info. If I ran either one of these operations I would strip them back down to make sure that the play by play is as close to live as possible. Remember, fans may be using this service as a replacement for the TV announcers who annoy us all. So you’ve got to be faster than they are now.

The bottom line — neither of the top two services is satisfying if you are doing nothing but concentrating on the screen, since they don’t stay “live” enough to hold your attention or keep your phone’s screen lit. I will keep looking to see if there are other services that concentrate solely on play by play, as well as trying to cobble together a Twitter stream to approximate play by play because Twitter is fast. We should have a Verizon phone in hand soon to test out the NFL Mobile app, and we have also heard that Yahoo has a pretty good service so we will look for that as well.

Anyone else out there figure this out? Chime in below in the comments.

(all photos credit: MSR.)

MSR Online Guide: San Francisco 49ers

OK kids, this is a real “beta” work in progress — but here is our first stab at a comprehensive online guide to all the pertinent links we could find for fans of the San Francisco 49ers, just in time for Sunday’s game at Cincinnati. Readers are encouraged to critique, compliment and add to this list — use the comments field below to tell us of other outlets, more Twitter handles and where Niner fans go to drown sorrows or celebrate victories before, during and after games.

OFFICIAL 49ERS TEAM SITE

CANDLESTICK PARK INFO

TWITTER HANDLES

LIVE TWEETS FROM THE GAME
Matt Maiocco (Comcast SportsNet)

NINERS PLAYERS
Vernon Davis
Patrick Willis
Dashon Goldson
Colin Kaepernick

LOCAL NEWSPAPERS THAT FOLLOW THE NINERS:
San Francisco Chronicle
San Jose Mercury News
San Francisco Examiner

LOCAL TV/RADIO/CABLE OUTLETS THAT FOLLOW THE NINERS:
Comcast SportsNet Bay Area
KNBR Radio
The Game 95.7 FM Radio
KRON Channel 4/Gary Radnich
NBC Bay Area
KTVU Channel 2
KGO TV (ABC affiliate)

BLOGGERS AND FAN GROUPS
SB Nation
Niners Nation
49ers Paradise
The Red Zone (49ers Forums)
49ers Web Zone

LOCAL SPORTS BARS
The American Bull
7 Mile House
Knuckles Sports Bar (at the airport Hyatt)

(information compiled by MSR intern Brian Nitenson)

ESPN’s New MNF Deal Shows That for Mobile Fans, the NFL Rules


Though the details of the new 8-year deal that ESPN and the NFL announced today are centered around broadcast rights for the popular Monday Night Football franchise, the incredible growth in viewership of digital ESPN NFL content is a sign that for mobile sports fans, football is king.

How big is mobile consumption getting? From the ESPN press release today, chew on these numbers for NFL content on the cable channel’s digital platforms:

— ESPN averaged 42.2 million unique visitors on the site in fall 2010; Sundays during the NFL season are the highest trafficked days of the year for ESPN.com

— During the 2010 season, NFL content represented 39% of the page views generated on ESPN.com, highest of any sport.

— The NFL fan spends over 50% more time with ESPN media than the average person;

— ESPN.com NFL coverage on Sunday and Monday (including the home page, NFL section and Fantasy Football section) averaged 47.4 million visits and 271.4 million minutes of usage during the 2010 season, a year-to-year increase of 20% on visits and 20% on minutes.

— NFL coverage (incl. NFL and Fantasy Football section) on the ESPN Mobile web site and ScoreCenter app in 2010 delivered 14.5 million visits and 101.4 million minutes each week, increases of 66% and 61%, respectively, versus the prior year.

With the season starting with tonight’s Green Bay/New Orleans matchup it will be interesting to see how many fans try to watch games on mobile platforms, either via direct connections (like Verizon’s NFL app or via the Sunday Ticket mobile platform) or through some other means like using a Slingbox. Clearly this is an area we’ll be watching closely so stay tuned for price and quality comparisons as the season rolls on.

Is 49ers vrs Raiders Fan Fight a Sign of the Times?

By now everybody that watches pro football is aware of the debacle that occurred at last weekend’s game between the San Francisco 49ers and the Oakland Raiders; two shootings and a beating, with fan fights continually breaking out all over the stadium.

Sad to say I am not surprised. This is not an indictment on the fans of either team, but rather for one of the rare moments I am in agreement with 49er team president Jed York, who said that these are not our regular fans. The sad thing is that they may well soon become his regular fans, and the same with many other teams across the nation. ( I think KissingSuzyKolber was wrong on this one)

I was a 49er season ticket holder for 25 years starting with the first year of Bill Walsh’s head coaching career there. We eagerly went to our first preseason game as ticket holders only to find a huge fight in the section below our seats. A friend claimed that at a Rams game in the early 70’s a Ram’s fan, after constant harassment, pulled a gun and threatened the people around him.

Preseason games were always nightmares. A much ruder, coarser, drunker group of fans tended to go. I think that Friday and Saturday games, particularly when it is warm, encourages drinking. For most fans there is no work the next day. We always gave our tickets away and so did all of our friends that had season tickets, and in the teams great years everybody wanted them, but as they continued their slide to mediocrity, at best, it was hard to give them away.

Many I have talked to have simply blamed the Raider fans but while 49er fans had developed a reputation as “chardonnay drinks’, as labeled by former offensive lineman Randy Cross- who incidentally the fans took a dislike to due to his movement penalty in the Superbowl that almost cost the game- but prior to that were considered some of the worst.

Former quarterback John Brodie once wrote about warning Colt’s great Johnny Unitas about the need to wear a helmet when leaving the field due to fans throwing bottles. After the team erected chicken wire around the field entrance fans started heating coins to drop through, he said. That was at Kezar Stadium, a place literally surrounded by bars.

However I see this in some aspects as the new generation of fans. People my age now preferred top buy a big screen and a broadcast package that allows you watch games in the comfort of your home. No $12 beers, $35 parking and all of the other expenses that you get at games. At least one city last year charged to tailgate. It is younger fans that are starting to fill the parks, and they seem to have a rougher edge. NFL owners are to blame, for the most part, in my humble opinion.

Three years ago Bill Simmons wrote at ESPN a very good piece on how teams destroy the tailgating experience for their most loyal fans. As you realize how badly the team treats you, viewing you as simply an ATM there for them to tap, it just makes sense to enjoy the game elsewhere.

So while teams build new palaces with which to play the games, attendance has been declining overall in the NFL. Certainly there are a number of factors, poor economy, high ticket prices, a number of teams being perennial doormats etc.. but it is becoming clearer to the average fan that the sightlines and cost are much better at home. Last year it was estimated that attendance was at its lowest level since 1998.

However no need to worry about fights at future 49er/Raiders games- it looks like that series has been canceled for the time being.